PR Nerd
PR Nerd
Training plans, running advice, and more.
← Back to articles
Garmin Forerunner 170 vs 265 vs Coros Pace 4: Which Budget Running Watch Should You Buy?
November 16, 2026·9 min read

Garmin Forerunner 170 vs 265 vs Coros Pace 4: Which Budget Running Watch Should You Buy?

Forerunner 170, Forerunner 265, or Coros Pace 4? How the three most popular mid-range running watches compare on GPS, battery, training features, music, and price.

0:000:00

If you're shopping for a running watch without spending flagship money, you've probably landed on the same three: the Garmin Forerunner 170, the Garmin Forerunner 265, and the Coros Pace 4.

They look a lot alike. All three have bright AMOLED touchscreens, weigh about 40 to 47 grams, and track the training data most runners actually use. But they're priced differently, and each one wins in a different area.

I've worn the Forerunner 255, the 265's predecessor, for almost three years, and I'm switching to Coros in January. Here's how the three compare, and which one I'd buy for different kinds of runners.

What's In This Guide

The Quick Answer

  • Best value: Coros Pace 4 ($249). Dual-band GPS, far more battery life than either Garmin, a triathlon mode, and offline maps, for the lowest price.
  • Best for most Garmin fans: Forerunner 170 ($299). Garmin's best training features, including Training Readiness and Garmin Pay, for $150 less than the 265.
  • Best all-around: Forerunner 265 ($449). Dual-band GPS, music on every model, triathlon mode, and two case sizes. It's the easy pick if you find it on sale.

Side by Side

Forerunner 170Forerunner 265Coros Pace 4
Price$299 ($349 Music)$449$249
GPSSingle-bandDual-bandDual-band
GPS batteryAbout 20 hours (GPS only), 14 hours (all systems)About 20 hoursUp to 41 hours (all systems)
Smartwatch batteryUp to 10 daysUp to 13 daysUp to 19 days
Weight41 g47 g (46mm)About 40 g
Case sizes43mm42mm or 46mm43mm
Training Readiness✓✓✗
Offline SpotifyMusic edition only✓✗ (MP3 only)
Contactless payments✓ Garmin Pay✓ Garmin Pay✗
Triathlon mode✗✓✓
Offline maps✗✗✓ (beta)
Buttons553, including a dial

What All Three Do Well

Before getting into the differences, it's worth knowing how much these watches share. All three:

  • Have bright AMOLED touchscreens that are easy to read in the sun.
  • Estimate your VO2 max and race times and tell you how long to recover after hard workouts. If you're curious how much to trust those numbers, see how accurate the Garmin race predictor is and how accurate Garmin's VO2 max is.
  • Track your training load so you can see whether you're building, maintaining, or overdoing it.
  • Measure running form metrics like cadence and ground contact time from the wrist.
  • Follow routes you've built ahead of time.
  • Are light enough to wear all day and overnight.

If you just want accurate pace, distance, heart rate, and smart training guidance, any of these three will make you happy. The differences come down to GPS, battery, a handful of features, and price.

Garmin Forerunner 170

The Forerunner 170 came out in May 2026, and it's Garmin's answer to "I want the good training features without paying for a 265."

What you get: Training Readiness, HRV Status, Training Status, the race predictor, VO2 max, recovery time, running power, Garmin Coach training plans, daily suggested workouts, and Garmin Pay. That's almost everything that makes the 265 great.

What you give up: The 170 uses single-band GPS instead of dual-band, so it can be less accurate in cities, under heavy tree cover, or on twisty trails. It has no triathlon mode. Music is only on the more expensive Forerunner 170 Music edition. And its GPS battery is the shortest of the three when all satellite systems are turned on.

Who it's for: Runners who mostly run roads and suburban routes, want to stay in Garmin's ecosystem, and want to save money. For a lot of runners, it closes almost the entire gap with the 265.

Garmin Forerunner 170
Garmin · New for 2026

Garmin Forerunner 170

Garmin's new mid-tier AMOLED watch, the direct upgrade from the 165 with a fuller sensor stack.

★ 4.7$299 MSRP
Check Price on Amazon →

Garmin Forerunner 265

The Forerunner 265 has been one of the most recommended running watches for years, and for good reason. It's the closest of the three to "does everything well."

What you get on top of the 170: dual-band GPS with Garmin's SatIQ, which switches to the most accurate mode when it needs to. Triathlon and multisport profiles. Training Load Focus, which shows whether your training is balanced between easy, hard, and very hard work. Offline music from Spotify, Amazon Music, and Deezer on every model. And two case sizes, with a bigger, sharper screen on the 46mm version.

What you give up: Mostly money. It's the most expensive of the three, and its battery life trails the Pace 4 by a lot.

Who it's for: Runners who run in cities or on trails where GPS gets tricky, triathletes, anyone who wants to leave their phone at home and still have music, or anyone who finds it on sale. Since newer watches have come out, the 265 is often discounted, and when it's close to the 170's price, it's the better buy for almost everyone.

Garmin Forerunner 265
Garmin · Best Overall Runner

Garmin Forerunner 265

The AMOLED sweet spot most runners actually need.

★ 4.7$449 MSRP
Check Price on Amazon →

Coros Pace 4

The Coros Pace 4 is the value pick, and it's not close. It's the cheapest of the three and has one of the highest user ratings of any running watch we track.

What you get: Dual-band GPS, which matches the 265 and beats the 170. Huge battery life, up to 41 hours of GPS in all-systems mode and up to 19 days as a smartwatch. A triathlon mode. Offline maps, which Coros rolled out in a public beta in September 2026. A built-in microphone for voice notes. And it's the lightest of the three.

What you give up: No Training Readiness score. No contactless payments. No offline Spotify, only MP3 files you load yourself. Three buttons and a dial instead of Garmin's five buttons, which some runners find easier to bump by accident. And it only works with Bluetooth sensors, not older ANT+ ones.

Who it's for: Runners who care most about training, GPS accuracy, and battery life, and don't need payments or streaming music. It's also a great fit for trail runners and triathletes on a budget.

I'm switching to Coros in January, but I'm going with the step-up Pace 4 Pro. I explain why in why Garmin dominates running watches, and why I'm switching to Coros, and the Pro gets the full treatment in our Coros Pace 4 Pro review.

Coros Pace 4
Coros

Coros Pace 4

The best all-around value in running watches right now.

★ 4.8$249 MSRP
Check Price on Amazon →

Which One Should You Buy?

Buy the Coros Pace 4 if:

  • You want the best GPS and battery life for the least money
  • You run trails, do triathlons, or want offline maps
  • You don't care about wrist payments or streaming music

Buy the Forerunner 170 if:

  • You want Garmin's ecosystem, Training Readiness, and Garmin Pay
  • You mostly run roads and open routes, where single-band GPS is fine
  • You want to save $150 compared to the 265

Buy the Forerunner 265 if:

  • You want dual-band GPS and Garmin's full feature set
  • You want offline Spotify without paying extra for a Music edition
  • You do triathlons, or you want the bigger 46mm screen
  • You find it on sale near the 170's price

One more thing: offline Spotify is a bigger deal than people think. If you like running without your phone, the 265 (or the 170 Music edition) is the way to go. Coros doesn't support it at all. I cover why that matters in why Garmin dominates running watches.

Still not sure? Our Watch Finder matches you to the right watch in four questions, and our running watch buying guide explains which features actually matter. For head-to-head details, see Forerunner 170 vs 265 and Coros Pace 4 vs Forerunner 170.

FAQ

Is the Forerunner 265 worth $150 more than the Forerunner 170? It is if you run where GPS accuracy suffers, like cities or under tree cover, if you do triathlons, or if you want offline music, a bigger screen, or Training Load Focus. For road runners on open routes, the 170 delivers almost the same training experience for less. If the 265 is on sale near the 170's price, buy the 265.

Is the Coros Pace 4 better than the Garmin Forerunner 170? For pure running, the Pace 4 offers more for less: dual-band GPS, much longer battery life, a triathlon mode, and offline maps in beta, for $50 less. The Forerunner 170 is better if you want Garmin Pay, Training Readiness, streaming music on the Music edition, and Garmin's ecosystem.

Which has the best battery life: Forerunner 170, Forerunner 265, or Coros Pace 4? The Coros Pace 4, by a wide margin. It's rated for up to 41 hours of GPS in all-systems mode and up to 19 days in smartwatch mode. The Forerunner 265 gets about 20 hours of GPS and up to 13 days as a smartwatch. The Forerunner 170 gets about 20 hours using GPS only, or about 14 hours with all systems, and up to 10 days as a smartwatch.

Does the Forerunner 170 have dual-band GPS? No. The Forerunner 170 uses single-band GPS. The Forerunner 265 and the Coros Pace 4 both have dual-band GPS, which is more accurate in cities, under trees, and on trails.

Does the Coros Pace 4 have Spotify? No. The Pace 4 can play MP3 files you load onto the watch yourself, but it doesn't support offline Spotify. The Forerunner 265 does, and so does the Forerunner 170 Music edition.

Which is the best running watch under $300? For most runners, the Coros Pace 4 at $249 is the best value. If you want to stay with Garmin, the Forerunner 170 at $299 is the pick.


PR Nerd is reader-supported. This article contains affiliate links. If you purchase through them, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you.


Share this article:
FacebookPost

Phil Parker
Written by

Phil Parker

Phil is a seasoned distance runner and web developer based in Iowa. He has run 15+ half marathons and 3 full marathons, and built PR Nerd because he was tired of paying for running apps that did not use real training science.

More about Phil →Follow on Strava →

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first.

Leave a comment

Not published

0/1000


Ready to put this into practice?

Build your free personalized training plan based on your actual fitness — not your goal.

Build my plan →
Join the Newsletter

Get monthly running research, pace strategies, and fresh training articles. Zero fluff.